My Quest for Mom Friends

By Published On: March 17th, 2022
Home > Motherhood > My Quest for Mom Friends

Building brand-new friendships with fellow mothers can be intimidating, but fear not—with a little determination (and maybe a bit of courage), you'll be on your way to finding a bestie with a baby.

I can’t remember where exactly I met Emma, but it was friendship at first sight. Her little boy was born right around the same time as my son, she lived only a couple blocks away, and we got along great. I really admired her humor and frankness, and it felt like we were having deeper conversations than the usual “So how are they sleeping?” or “How’s breastfeeding going?”

True, we’d only known each other for a short time—like a week—but I was really feeling the connection. I’d found a new mom friend! Our boys would grow up together and be best buds! Visions of morning playdates, dinner parties and late-night chit chats danced in my head.

And then she stopped responding to my texts.

I was stunned and confused. Maybe she was just busy or out of town, I reasoned. Surely she, too, had felt that fellow-mom friendship spark. I mean, a connection like that couldn’t have just been one-sided, right?

Something must be up in her life, I rationalized. If I just waited it out, our inevitable best friend-ness would come to fruition. But I never did hear from Emma again. In fact, the next time I saw her and her son was in a picture posted on social media … in another new mom acquaintance’s post. Emma had dumped me—at least that’s how it felt.

Know It Might Take Time

Meeting people and making real connections with other women as an adult is hard. Toss in the demands of caring for a newborn, and it gets even harder. Most of my inner circle is made up of ladies I met back in school or college, and they haven’t yet had children. I love this group of friends, but when I had my baby I wanted to bond with women experiencing the same things I was in my life. After all, creating, birthing and raising a new human are pretty big things that I longed to talk about with other mothers going through these changes. I wanted a support group.

I thought I needed pals who were also parents, so I started consciously seeking them out. I didn’t realize how difficult, uncomfortable and—sometimes—hurtful the process of making new mom friends would be.

Some of these experiences, like with Emma, stung. There were other times I tried—and failed—at making mommy friends, too. I stalked potential playdates at the playground and worried if they liked me (like dating, but with a newborn). And I was banished from a mom group, high-school-style, for not fitting in. (Hey, mean girls grow up and have babies, too.)

Eventually, I had to learn to not take it personally and start trusting the process, which was easier said than done.

Ditch the Pressure for Perfection

At times, I’ve felt like my failure to make mom friends made me a failure as a mother. Would my babies grow up to be friendless little hermits because I couldn’t lock down another mom for music class meet-ups or playgroups? Was my inability to make good friends in motherhood stunting my kid’s development, ruining his chances at future success?

Of course not, say the experts. The only social interaction young babies really need is from their family. (Whew—sigh of relief!) Friends don’t come into play for them until they’re a little older, in the toddler and preschool years. And even then, the most important thing for our children’s development is feeling safe and loved by their parents.

“When it comes to moms making friends with other new moms, it’s likely that the benefits in the earliest months skew toward the moms rather than their babies,” says Laura A. Jana, MD, spokesperson for the American Academy of Pediatrics and author of The Toddler Brain: Nurture the Skills Today that Will Shape Your Child’s Tomorrow. “The take-home message for new moms? Don’t add any additional stress to your new parenting life.”

Keep Your Eyes Open for all Possibilities

Still, it hurts. I thought that after I got married, and thereby stopped the dating process, my feelings of rejection from another person would end. But alas, my attempts at making mom friends introduced me to rejection of a new sort. I had to shift my mindset: Just as every guy isn’t going to be The One, every woman isn’t going to be The BFF. And that’s OK. Luckily, I’ve succeeded a few times.

I met a lovely woman via a Craigslist ad she posted looking for a mom friend. (Yes, I stooped to Craigslist to make friends—and it worked!) I reconnected with a former colleague who happened to get pregnant shortly after I did and whose own friendship tribe hadn’t gotten around to having kids yet, either. We hadn’t been that close before our babies were born, but now we see each other frequently at story times and birthday parties.

My neighbor, who’d been friendly in passing before but nothing more, had a little boy five months before I did, and we grow closer every day. My childless friends stepped up, too, taking a greater interest in my kids than I expected for women enjoying the single life.

I still stress out about not knowing enough babies and toddlers to invite to birthday parties and feel, sometimes, like I’m letting my kids down due to my own failings to make new friends. But I’ve also learned that, at least for right now at this early stage in their lives, I’m enough for them, and my tried-and-true childless friends can be just as there for my kids
as they have always been for me.

Utilize Modern Resources

If you’re an introvert and the idea of small talk is too painful, or if you simply don’t know where to start in the pursuit of friendship, online resources may be a good place to start. (And no, I don’t mean Craigslist, though you can’t knock it till you try it.)

Just like dating in today’s world, apps now connect parents, too! The Peanut app matches moms based off similarities, like age of children, lifestyle preferences and location. For example, if you’re specifically looking for stay-at-home moms in New York City who enjoy jogging-stroller exercise groups and limit screen time for their kiddos, you can search for those types of connections with Peanut.

Similarly, Facebook groups are another way to meet like-minded moms before taking the leap to get together. Joining a group for tandem breastfeeding or homeschooling acts as the ice breaker for conversation. Bonding over something important to the both of you is a great first move toward your (hopefully) beautiful friendship.

By Allyson Reedy