How to identify—and survive—your baby's chronic crying condition.
Babies cry. As a mom of three, I can attest to that fact. However, when my third baby was about 5 weeks old, my husband and I began to notice that his daily demeanor was taking a turn for the worse. He would fuss pretty consistently in the evening hours, even after we changed him, or fed him, or rocked him in an attempt to get him to go to sleep. And it became next to impossible to put him down —ever. But I remembered that my other kids had gone through a similar patch of unhappiness in their second months, and so I chalked it up to new baby malaise, expecting it to last a week or so and then dissipate like it had with the first two.
But instead of getting better, it got worse. One week of crying turned into two, and then two turned into three, and finally after a solid month of escalating inconsolable crying jags that lasted for several hours every day, I finally conceded to the miserable fact: My baby had colic.
Crying by any other name Looking back, I’m surprised I didn’t figure it out sooner, but the truth is, I hesitated to call the problem colic because I didn’t understand exactly what colic was. How was I supposed to determine when the problem had moved from normal fussy baby behavior to an abnormal condition? Robert Sears, MD, a well-known pediatrician and author in the Sears Parenting Library, who has written and spoken extensively about colic, helps parents get some answers to this frustrating and all-too-common problem. He explains: “There is no real official definition [for colic]. Some doctors use the ‘rule of threes’: crying more than three hours a day, for at least three days a week, lasting more than three weeks. But there is no actual research that supports this definition. The way I see it, babies are supposed to be happy. They should feed, burp, spit up a little, cry for brief periods for a legitimate reason (like diaper changes, dressing, overly tired, hungry), sleep, and have awake periods where they coo and goo and look at mom and dad. They should not cry nonstop for hours and hours.”
If your baby can’t be calmed for long stretches of time on a consistent basis, chances are, you’re looking at colic. Even if your baby isn’t meeting the “criteria” for colic but you sense something isn’t right, it’s reason enough to see your pediatrician. “Parents have an intuition that something is wrong, [that] their baby is hurting,” says Sears. “Don’t let a doctor tell you nothing’s wrong, and that babies are supposed to cry like that.”
Making a list, checking it twice As irrational as I knew it was, there was part of me that worried we were causing the problem somehow. Or worse, that there was something serious lurking inside making him hurt. We craved answers—or at least a direction that might lead to an explanation—so to the pediatrician we went.
According to Sears, if you bring your baby into your healthcare provider with questions about colic, he or she will want to examine your baby thoroughly to check for any obvious signs of pain. “[The doctor will look for] ear infection (usually the baby would have cold symptoms), fever, throat infection, mouth sores, insect bites, scratched eye (eye will likely be red), hair tourniquet (a piece of long hair wrapped tightly around a finger or toe), broken bone (look for swelling and pain), hernia (swelling of the scrotum) or severe diaper rash. Constipation and bladder infection may also be causes of painful crying.” If baby gets the all clear for these, the next stop in colic troubleshooting is the digestive system.
The most common culprit of intestinal issues in infants involves intake of dairy or other food allergens, which cause excessive gas and other tummy discomfort. “There are three primary causes that I see in my office: cow’s milk protein allergy (from cow’s milk formula or from cow’s milk proteins in a breastfeeding mom’s diet), Transient Lactase Deficiency (TLD, a form of temporary lactose intolerance in which baby can’t properly digest milk sugar), and other food allergies through a breastfeeding mom’s diet,” reports Sears. The way to determine if a substance is aggravating your little one’s system is to remove it from the scene—whether eliminating it from a breastfeeding mom’s diet or switching to a soy-based formula—and see what happens. If there is no change, your doctor may suggest an over- the-counter treatment of lactase digestive enzymes that breaks down milk sugars in breast milk or formula. “These two steps cover the most common causes of colicky symptoms. If breastfed babies don’t show improvement within another week, I’ll have mom remove other colicky foods from her diet, such as gluten, soy, nuts, eggs and corn.”
Mind over matter The chance that I could potentially solve the problem by changing my diet was a motivator for me, and I started by happily tossing all my dairy products out the window. I was told it would take a week at most to see a change, and so when the crying had not abated by day two, I still held out hope. By day five, my optimism started flagging. After seven days of no change, I drowned my sorrows in a bowl of mint chocolate chip and began feeling a real despair.
At this point it felt as though we had tried everything, including drops to relieve gas, probiotics for me and for him to aid digestion, an antacid prescription in case of reflux, an earlier bedtime to preempt overtiredness, a later bedtime when that didn’t work, babywearing for closeness, “colic holding” to put gentle pressure on his belly, stroller walking to change the scenery, porch swinging for a constant motion, music for distraction, pacifiers for sucking comfort, teething tablets and acetaminophen in case of gum pain, constant nursing to combat hunger, spaced out nursing in case of overfeeding, bathing for water therapy … the list of our attempts was long. And I was tired.
Also, I was sad. I was sad that all anyone was getting to see of my sweet boy was a scrunched up red face and a look of unhappiness. I worried that no one would want to be around him. Babies are dubbed “good” when they are smiley, quiet, docile. Did that mean my baby was “bad”?
And the crying was taking a toll on me too. More than once I had to lay him down and leave the room, to give my frazzled nerves (and ears) a break from the noise and shed a few tears of my own. Dealing with my baby’s colic was an unrelenting slog, and I was close to coming unhinged.
Coming out of the dark What I know now is that those emotions are completely normal, and it’s important for parents to recognize that dealing with colic is a legitimately stressful experience. “Realize that you may not be able to do this alone,” counsels Sears. “Get some relief from friends and family; let them take baby for an hour or two while you get out of the house—and out of earshot. Set up a relief schedule so you have some time to look forward to.” Don’t beat yourself up over things like a messy house or unanswered emails. Your baby’s wellbeing is important, and so is yours. Most of all, keep reminding yourself that this is just a phase, and it will come to an end.
We never did receive a definitive diagnosis or figure out a magical solution for our baby’s unhappiness. One day, right around the 3-month mark, he simply stopped crying. Now at 7 months, he is easygoing and happy—a joy to be around. It may be impossible to imagine in the thick of those colicky weeks or months, but it’s true: Colic won’t last forever. So hang in there. Call in reserves. Take a reprieve. Take a nap. And know that better days are just around the bend.
For almost two decades, Pregnancy & Newborn has been the trusted resource for credible and relatable knowledge that moms need to make the best choices for their lifestyles. We stand beside every woman during the beauty, the chaos and all the moments of motherhood.